Comparison of Emergencies in the Indian Constitution

1. National Emergency has the most sweeping powers, affecting both central and state governance, while also impacting citizens' Fundamental Rights.
2. Constitutional Emergency (President’s Rule), though limited to individual states, has been frequently used as a political tool, leading to critiques about overreach by the Centre.
3. Financial Emergency, though never invoked, could have severe implications for the country’s economy, especially in times of financial crisis, by centralizing control over fiscal policies.

Download PDF

Below 

Comparison of Emergencies in the Indian Constitution

Criteria	National Emergency (Article 352)	Constitutional Emergency (President's Rule) (Article 356)	Financial Emergency (Article 360)
Grounds for Declaration	- Declared due to: 1. War, 2. External Aggression, or 3. Armed Rebellion (formerly internal disturbance). - Can be declared for part or the whole country.	- Declared when there is a breakdown of constitutional machinery in a state (failure of state government to operate as per the Constitution). - Also referred to as President's Rule.	- Declared when there is a threat to the financial stability or credit of India or any part thereof. - Aimed at preventing or addressing a national economic crisis.
Parliamentary Approval	Approval required by both Houses of Parliament by special majority. - Must be approved within 1 month of proclamation. - If Parliament is not in session, the President may issue the proclamation and it must be ratified later.	- Must be approved by both Houses by special majority within 2 months of proclamation. - Continued approval needed every 6 months thereafter to keep it in force.	- Must be approved by both Houses by special majority within 2 months of proclamation. - No specific term limits on the continuation of this emergency.
Revocation of Proclamation	- Can be revoked by the President at any time. - The Lok Sabha can also pass a resolution to revoke the proclamation by a simple majority.	- Can be revoked by the President at any time.	- Can be revoked by the President at any time.
Duration and Implementation	- Has been invoked three times in India’s history: 1. 1962 (Indo-China war), 2. 1971 (Indo-Pak war), 3. 1975 (Internal emergency under Indira Gandhi's government).	- Has been invoked more than 115 times in Indian states. - It allows the President to take over the functions of the state government and even dissolve the state assembly.	- Never invoked in India’s history. - Would allow the Central Government to direct states on financial matters, including the reduction of salaries of government employees.
Judicial Review	- Judicial review is permitted, and courts can examine the validity of the proclamation, particularly after the 44th Amendment, which restricts the scope of misuse.	- Judicial review is permitted. The courts have reviewed the validity of the proclamation, particularly if it violates any provisions of federalism or constitutional governance.	- Judicial review is permitted. However, as it has never been invoked, its review is theoretical.
Impact on Fundamental Rights	- During a national emergency, Fundamental Rights under Article 19 can be suspended. - The President can also suspend the right to move courts for the enforcement of other Fundamental Rights (except Articles 20 and 21).	- No automatic suspension of Fundamental Rights. However, state governance comes under central control, which can lead to restrictions on civil liberties indirectly.	- No direct impact on Fundamental Rights, but economic measures might affect the financial stability of citizens, potentially leading to restrictions on economic activities.
Key Constitutional Provisions	- Article 352 of the Indian Constitution governs National Emergency. - Related Articles include Article 358 and Article 359.	- Article 356 governs the provisions for Constitutional Emergency or President's Rule. - This Article is based on Section 93 of the Government of India Act, 1935.	- Article 360 governs the provisions for Financial Emergency.

---

Download PDF here 

emergency provision